The panel aims to draw a critical map of emergent schools, artists, architects, and research centers, focusing on the contemporary processes of "urbanity in the making." To sketch these perspectives, we propose three interpretive metaphors inspired by the literature on African cities: the black swan, the grey rhino, and the elephant in the room. The black swan captures the shock of alterity and the emergence of unexpected events; the grey rhino emphasizes the underlying and often ignored risks of existing systems; and the elephant in the room exposes the denials and blind spots embedded within dominant governance and planning frameworks. Taken together, these metaphors provide a critical lens for understanding complex challenges and the distinct contributions of African urbanism. We propose them as a framework to critically analyze urban practices, planning cultures, and higher education approaches that interact in vital ways within contemporary African contexts. The panel welcomes proposals that contribute to this effort, especially those that focus on proactive and contextually relevant strategies for the future role of African perspectives on a global level. This panel is part of the development of the forthcoming Routledge volume: African Approaches to Urban Planning: Towards Novel Alignments of Urban Practice, Planning Cultures, and Higher Education.
Africanizing urban planning: from dispossession to empowerment
Prof. Dr. Armelle Choplin | University of Geneva | Switzerland
Show details
Author:
Prof. Dr. Armelle Choplin | University of Geneva | Switzerland
During UN Habitat Day on 30 October 2025, Senegal's Minister of Urban Planning and Housing stated: 'We need to build 500,000 homes by 2050. But we don't have any urban planners.” Until recently, West African countries were deprived of the power to design cities: master plans were usually designed by foreign consulting firms with urban planners trained outside the continent and financed by aid agencies. Planning (Planification stratégique in French) was a kind of neo-colonial privilege reserved for Western countries. However, over the past two decades, things have changed. This paper analyses the undergoing transformation of the construction sector, with the emergence of various new players: presidents, who are launching major urban projects; real estate developers, who are acting as investors and improvising as architects and planners; elites and diaspora members, who are urbanising large suburban areas; construction contractors, who are producing materials and buildings... The reappropriation of the power to design cities is also being facilitated by new architecture and urban planning training programmes being established in West Africa (Senegal, Togo, Benin and Mauritania). This local reappropriation is also visible through in the emergence of various collectives, particularly among architects, who promote more sustainable building approaches. This crucial moment of (re)empowerment in urban planning raises the question of what kind of urban future is envisioned. Will it be desirable? Which models are currently in circulation (romanticized vernacular architecture Vs. capitalist, techno-optimist megaprojects)? Who will benefit from this new empowerment?
Paradoxical Futures: Participatory Design and Planning in a Divided City
Dr. Laurin Baumgardt | EPFL | Switzerland
Show details
Author:
Dr. Laurin Baumgardt | EPFL | Switzerland
Three decades after the end of South Africa’s apartheid regime, Cape Town remains a highly fractured and deeply divided city. Bearing the scars of colonial oppression and apartheid-era planning, it offers little prospect for systemic transformation and change. Based on long-term ethnographic research conducted in Cape Town, this paper examines how community architects, housing activists, and other civil society and built environment professionals have developed alternative participatory planning and design initiatives in response to the urgent needs of residents living in flood- and fire-prone informal settlements. Focusing on practices such as incremental housing upgrades, community-led design processes, informal settlement upgrading, and experimental building typologies, the paper explores how some of these initiatives seek to reconfigure dominant planning cultures and imaginaries of urban development. At the same time, the paper critically interrogates some of the limits, blind spots, and paradoxes embedded within such interventions (the “grey rhinos” and “elephants in the room”). While often framed as participatory and imaginative interventions that envision alternative urban futures and improved infrastructural conditions, these initiatives may also perpetuate existing exclusions, defer more structural transformations, or become enmeshed in the paradoxes produced through the institutionalization of participatory planning. By situating these alternative planning and design practices within broader debates on African urbanism, architecture, urban anthropology, and infrastructural politics, the paper contributes to discussions of emergent approaches and design practices in African cities. In short, the paper offers a critical appreciation of experimental interventions that may reflect urban futures in the making yet risk reinforcing familiar trajectories.
Beyond Model Transfer: African Perspectives on Community Led Housing
Dr. Laura Colini | University Iuav of Venice | Italy
Show details
Authors:
Dr. Laura Colini | University Iuav of Venice | Italy
Dr. Claire Simonneau | Université Gustave Eiffel
African housing research has largely foregrounded state-led delivery, market mechanisms, and informal settlement upgrading while the recent Community-Led Housing (CLH) research in Africa, unevenly theorized and little implemented, highlights the promise for an alternative institutional logic that integrates permanent affordability with collective agency and community control. By reviewing the extant literature on multisite case studies in Africa, this paper critically reviews the emerging literature on community-led, collective, and non-speculative housing approaches in Africa to advance three main perspectives: it looks at the socio-legal and planning process sustaining CLH not as a stabilised institutional form but rather shaped through negotiation across plural legal orders and shifting relations with public authorities. It draws attention to the way community organisation in dense urban areas is treated separately from community-led finance in the international literature on African housing. It questions the non-speculative mechanisms brought to the fore by the circulation of Community Land Trusts (CLTs) in areas where land and real estate markets are a means of savings, and a significant source of added value that acts as a safety net for livelihoods.
By identifying potential analytical gaps especially regarding institutional integration, socio-legal negotiation, and the politics of collective tenure, this paper positions African perspectives on CLH and planning not as derivative adaptations of established housing models but as proactive and contextually grounded approaches. It suggests that CLH in Africa should be understood as a process that reframes land governance, social justice, and planning practice, ultimately considering African experiences as theoretically generative.